echelon

SEO vs PPC: How to Choose, and How to Use Both Together

Short answer: SEO and PPC are the two ways to appear on Google. SEO (search engine optimization) earns free, organic listings over time and keeps working after the effort is done. PPC (pay per click), such as Google Ads, puts paid ads at the top of the results within days, but stops the moment you […]

seo vs ppc
In this post12 sections

Short answer: SEO and PPC are the two ways to appear on Google. SEO (search engine optimization) earns free, organic listings over time and keeps working after the effort is done. PPC (pay per click), such as Google Ads, puts paid ads at the top of the results within days, but stops the moment you stop paying. Choose PPC when you need enquiries quickly, SEO when you want lasting results at a lower cost per customer, and both when you can, because each makes the other work better.

If you have searched for this, you have probably read that “it depends”. It does, but it depends on a few things you can work out for yourself. This guide compares SEO and PPC side by side, shows how to compare their return on investment with your own numbers, and explains which to start with if you are a new business.

What is SEO?

SEO is the work of improving your website and online presence so you appear higher in Google’s unpaid results and on Google Maps. It includes writing useful pages, making your website fast and easy to use, managing your Google Business Profile and earning links and reviews. You do not pay Google for clicks. You pay with time, or by hiring help.

What is PPC?

PPC stands for pay per click. You bid to show ads for chosen keywords, and you pay when someone clicks. On Google, PPC means Google Ads. The ads appear in spaces marked “Sponsored”. You control the budget, the keywords, the area and the times your ads run. Our guide to how Google Ads works explains the auction in detail.

SEO vs PPC at a glance

SEO PPC
Where you appear Organic results and the Google Maps pack “Sponsored” ad spaces, usually top and bottom of the page
How you pay Time, content and expertise; no cost per click Per click, set by an auction
Speed Slow; usually months to build Fast; ads can run as soon as they are approved
How long results last Rankings can keep bringing visitors after the work Visitors stop when the budget stops
Control You influence rankings but cannot buy a position You control keywords, location, schedule, budget and ad text
Targeting By the topics and areas your pages cover Precise: town, radius, time of day, device, audience lists
Trust Earned through good content, reviews and Maps listings Clearly labelled as ads; useful when people need help fast
Testing Changes take weeks to show New ads and offers can be tested within days
Cost per customer over time Often falls as rankings grow Stays tied to click prices and competition
Best for Lasting visibility, research-heavy purchases, local searches Launches, offers, urgent services, filling gaps

The key differences in detail

Cost

With PPC, every click costs money, and the price is set by how many others want the same keyword. Emergency and legal services usually cost much more per click than routine local services. Our guide to Google Ads costs in the UK, published on 10 November, gives real examples from Google’s keyword data.

With SEO, there is no cost per click, but there is a cost in time or fees for content, technical work and local SEO. That cost is not linked to the number of visitors, so the cost per visitor usually falls as your rankings grow.

Speed

PPC can bring visitors on the first day. SEO usually takes months, and longer in competitive industries. Our article on how long SEO takes to show results explains why.

How long results last

PPC traffic stops when you stop paying. Good SEO results tend to last, although rankings need upkeep as competitors and Google change.

Control and testing

PPC gives you close control: you can change an ad, a budget or a target area today and see the effect this week. SEO is slower to adjust, but the content you build keeps its value.

Trust and clicks

Organic results and Google Maps listings with good reviews carry a lot of trust. Ads, on the other hand, can take the very top of the page. Appearing in both places makes your business look established.

Which gives the better return on investment?

There is no honest average that applies to every business. The best way to answer this is with your own numbers.

Step 1: Work out what a new customer is worth. Use the average profit from a customer, including repeat work. For example, if an average job brings £300 profit and customers often come back once, a new customer might be worth £600 in profit.

Step 2: Work out the cost per customer from PPC. Divide your monthly ad spend plus any management fee by the number of customers the ads brought that month.

Step 3: Work out the cost per customer from SEO. Divide your monthly SEO cost (fees, or the value of your own time) by the number of customers that came from organic search and Google Maps.

Step 4: Compare, and look at the trend. PPC often shows a return sooner. SEO often starts with a higher cost per customer, then falls as rankings grow, because more customers arrive without a matching rise in cost.

To compare fairly, you need to track calls, forms and sales from each channel. That usually needs cookies or similar tracking, so follow the ICO’s guidance on cookies and similar technologies when you set it up.

When PPC makes sense

  • You need enquiries now, for example because you have just opened or have quiet weeks to fill.
  • You have a time-limited offer or event.
  • Your service is urgent, such as emergency plumbing or locksmiths, where people click the first good option.
  • You want to test demand for a new service before investing in content.
  • Your organic rankings are still growing, and you want to fill the gap.

Whether PPC is worth it for a small business depends on your margins and how well you answer enquiries. Our article on whether PPC is worth it for small businesses goes into more detail.

When SEO makes sense

  • You want steady enquiries without paying for every click.
  • Your customers research before buying, reading guides and comparing options.
  • You serve local areas and want to appear in the Google Maps pack. Our local SEO checklist is a good place to start.
  • You are building for the long term and want an asset that grows in value.
  • Click prices in your industry are high, so ranking organically saves a lot of money over time.

Should a new business start with SEO or PPC?

Most new businesses need enquiries quickly and have no rankings yet, so PPC often comes first, with the SEO basics started at the same time. But it depends on your situation.

Your situation Start with Why
New business, need work this month PPC, plus SEO basics Ads bring calls while your website and Business Profile build trust
New business, very small budget SEO basics and Google Business Profile first Free visibility, then a small PPC test once you can afford it
Customers search urgently PPC and Google Business Profile People choose fast from the top of the page and the map
Customers research for weeks SEO, with a small PPC campaign Helpful content wins trust during long decisions
Very competitive local market Both PPC for visibility now, SEO for lower costs later
Online shop PPC (including Shopping ads) and SEO for category pages Shopping ads show products at once; SEO builds lasting traffic

SEO basics for every new business: a fast website with a page for each main service and area, a complete Google Business Profile, a steady flow of genuine reviews and correct business details on directories. Our guide to digital marketing on a small budget has more low-cost ideas.

How to use SEO and PPC together

SEO and PPC work best as a team. Here is how each helps the other.

1. Share keyword data

PPC shows you within weeks which searches turn into enquiries. Use those keywords to plan SEO pages. In return, your organic search data in Google Search Console can reveal useful keywords to add to your ads.

2. Test messages quickly

Try different headlines and offers in your ads. When one gets more clicks, use the same wording in your page titles and meta descriptions.

3. Take more space on the page

When you appear in both the ads and the organic results for an important search, people see your name twice. That builds recognition and pushes competitors further down.

4. Protect your brand name

If competitors bid on your business name, a low-cost ad on your own name keeps you at the top. Strong SEO for your brand name supports this.

5. Build landing pages that serve both

A fast, clear page that matches what people searched for helps your ads’ quality and your organic rankings. Our guide to PPC landing page design explains what makes a page convert.

6. Shift budget as SEO grows

As you start to rank well organically for a keyword, test reducing ad spend on it and moving that budget to keywords where you do not yet rank.

Common mistakes when choosing between SEO and PPC

  • Treating it as either/or, when most businesses benefit from both.
  • Stopping SEO after a few weeks because results are slow.
  • Running PPC without conversion tracking, so you cannot see the return.
  • Sending ads to the homepage instead of a matching page.
  • Judging SEO by rankings alone instead of enquiries and sales.

If you want to understand how paid search fits into the bigger picture, read our guide to SEO vs SEM.

Getting help with SEO and PPC

We offer both SEO and PPC, so we can plan them together and use what we learn from one to improve the other. See our SEO services in Essex and PPC management in Essex, our London services for SEO and PPC, or our digital marketing services if you want both managed together.

Frequently asked questions

Is SEO or PPC better?

Neither is better for every business. PPC is faster and gives close control, but stops when you stop paying. SEO is slower but builds lasting visibility and usually brings a lower cost per customer over time. Many businesses use PPC for quick results while SEO grows.

Is Google AdWords the same as PPC?

Google AdWords, now called Google Ads, is the most common PPC platform. PPC is the wider term for any advertising where you pay per click, which also includes Microsoft Advertising and many social media ads.

What do CPC, CPM, CPA and CTR mean?

CPC is cost per click: what you pay for one click. CPM is cost per thousand impressions: what you pay for your ad to be shown 1,000 times. CPA is cost per acquisition: what you pay, on average, for one customer or lead. CTR is click-through rate: the share of people who saw your ad and clicked it.

Can a small business afford both SEO and PPC?

Yes. Neither needs a big budget to start. A common approach is a small, focused PPC campaign for your most valuable service, plus the SEO basics such as your Google Business Profile, reviews and good service pages. As organic results grow, you can move budget between the two.

Book a chinwag

Tell us what you sell and who buys it. We will say what we would do first, what we would skip, and what it costs.

Or message us on WhatsApp. The Barn, Venn Farm, Tudwick Road, Tiptree, Essex, CO5 0SD.